24
Music Royalties in the Digital Age
Posted by Strada | Posted in Business, Industry | Posted on 24-11-2009
Assuming an independent musician has no record label, is the sole songwriter and owns their copyright and has digital distribution for a flat annual fee - How would they earn royalties from the sources below? Who collects and pays the royalties for each?
- Non interactive radio (Pandora)
Answer: There’s some question whether Pandora is “interactive” but for now, a court has held it is not. Assuming that’s correct, there is a compulsory license under the copyright law for the masters, and the monies are collected by a nonprofit company called Soundexchange.
ASCAP / BMI (performing rights societies) collect for the songwriting.
The artist (who is also the record company and publisher in this example) affiliates with each of these companies for payment.
- Streaming services (Spotify)
Answer: Interactive streaming requires a license for the master from the company; there is no compulsory license, so they can charge whatever they can get. There are “aggregators” (like Tunecore and Orchard) who put together small companies and re-license the digital rights to masters. That would make sense for an owner/user like this example, because it’s hard to get streaming services to make one-off deals.
Songwriting is collected by ASCAP / BMI.
- Digital downloads (iTunes)
Answer: Master rights are also licensed directly, or through aggregators, as above.
Publishing rights are done directly, or through Harry Fox.
- Subscription download service (eMusic)
Answer: I assume you mean a streaming subscription with a number of downloads included? If so, they need all the licenses above.
- Video streaming (YouTube)
Answer: The record company makes a deal with the site. Songwriting isn’t totally settled. Mostly, the record company gets paid by the site directly, then pays the songwriter / publisher.


